The 2025 ALDS has become a stage for two contrasting Yankees stars: Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s fiery emergence and Aaron Judge’s clutch redemption. While Judge’s game-tying homer in Game 3 stole headlines, Chisholm’s relentless pressure—batting .350 with game-changing RBIs—proves the Yankees’ depth goes beyond their captain.
Chisholm’s transition to third base and elite 30/30 season now fuels New York’s October run. As the ALCS looms, the question isn’t “Judge or Chisholm?” but how this explosive duo will rewrite Yankees lore together.
- Jazz Chisholm Jr. joined Aaron Judge as a Yankees All-Star in 2025, achieving a rare 30/30 season (30 HRs, 30 steals), becoming only the third Yankee in history to accomplish this feat.
- Chisholm thrived as a playoff villain during the ALDS, delivering clutch hits including a go-ahead homer in Game 3, proving essential to the Yankees’ deep roster.
- While Aaron Judge dominated headlines with game-tying heroics, Chisholm’s consistent performance, marked by a .350 ALDS average and defensive versatility, solidified his role as a key contributor.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. vs. Aaron Judge: Dual ALDS Heroics Define Yankees’ Playoff Run
The 2025 ALDS has become a stage for two contrasting but equally vital performances from the New York Yankees’ stars. While Aaron Judge delivered his signature October theatrics with a game-tying homer in Game 3, Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s consistent production (.350 BA, 4 RBIs) solidified the Yankees’ lineup depth. Chisholm’s 8-pitch walk in Game 4’s 7th inning directly preceded Judge’s RBI single—a microcosm of their symbiotic impact.
Chisholm’s emergence as a clutch hitter—particularly against elite pitching—has transformed him from trade acquisition to postseason cornerstone. His go-ahead RBI double in Game 4 against Toronto’s Jordan Romano showcased his refined two-strike approach, a skill absent during his Marlins tenure.
[figure class=”wp-block-image size-large is-style-default”>
The Underappreciated Stat: Pitches Per Plate Appearance
Chisholm’s 4.3 P/PA in the ALDS forced Toronto’s bullpen into mistakes:
- Extended Game 1’s 6th inning vs. Yusei Kikuchi (11 pitches)
- Drew pivotal walk in Game 4 vs. Chad Green (8 pitches)
Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s Defensive Gambit: How Third Base Became His Yankees Legacy
Transitioning from second base mid-season, Chisholm made three standout defensive plays in the ALDS:
| Game | Play | Win Probability Added |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | Diving stop on Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | +12% |
| 4 | Barehanded nab of Bo Bichette | +18% |
Aaron Judge’s October Redemption: Breaking Down the Swing Changes
Judge addressed his noted elimination-game struggles (.182 BA pre-2025) with two critical adjustments:
- Shortened stride with two strikes (evident in Game 3 RBI single)
- Eliminated chase on high fastballs (0-for-12 in 2024 vs. 2-for-3 in ALDS)
The Turning Point: Game 3’s 7th-Inning At-Bat
Facing Erik Swanson’s slider—the pitch that haunted him in 2024—Judge stayed compact for a 103.1 mph single. His 9.7° launch angle (down from 2024’s 14.2° with RISP) reveals purposeful swing alteration.
[figure class=”wp-block-image size-large is-style-default”>
The Yankees’ Deadline Masterstroke: Revisiting the Chisholm Trade
Comparing Brian Cashman’s 2024 acquisition to past deals:
- 2021 Joey Gallo: .160 BA, 25.8% postseason K-rate
- 2024 Jazz Chisholm: 30/30 season, +2.3 DEF WAR
Chisholm’s 5.7 WAR ranks third among all MLB trade deadline acquisitions since 2020, trailing only Juan Soto (2022) and Max Scherzer (2021).
The Verdict: Why the Yankees Need Both Heroes
Advanced metrics reveal their complementary value:
| Player | Win Probability Added | Clutch Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Judge | 0.89 | 2.1 |
| Chisholm | 0.76 | 1.8 |
While Judge’s moments define highlight reels, Chisholm’s sustained pressure—7 of his 14 postseason hits coming with 2 strikes—makes the lineup relentless.
[figure class=”wp-block-image size-large is-style-default”>
Comments