Tommy DeVito Cut by Giants: Why the Fan-Favorite QB Was Released and What’s Next for the Underdog Star

The New York Giants have made a tough roster decision, releasing fan-favorite quarterback Tommy DeVito as they finalized their 53-man squad. Known affectionately as “Tommy Cutlets,” the undrafted underdog captured hearts in 2023 with his local roots and surprising 3-3 record as a starter.

With veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston leading the QB room, plus rookie Jaxson Dart added to the mix, DeVito became the odd man out. His departure marks the end of a memorable two-year stint that turned the New Jersey native into a cultural phenomenon.

Tommy DeVito Cut by Giants: Why the Fan-Favorite QB Was Released

Tommy DeVito, the beloved quarterback affectionately nicknamed “Tommy Cutlets,” has been released by the New York Giants. The decision came as the team finalized its 53-man roster, leaving fans heartbroken but not entirely surprised. With the addition of veteran quarterbacks Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, and the emergence of rookie Jaxson Dart, DeVito became the odd man out in a crowded QB room. The Giants’ coaching staff faced a tough choice, but the reality of NFL roster limits made DeVito’s departure inevitable.

DeVito’s journey with the Giants was nothing short of remarkable. From an undrafted free agent to starting quarterback, he captured the hearts of fans with his resilience and charisma. His 2023 season, where he led the team to a 3-3 record as a starter, showcased his potential. However, his inconsistent performances in 2024 and the team’s commitment to veterans ultimately sealed his fate.

While it’s tough to see a fan favorite go, the Giants made the right move. Carrying four quarterbacks is a luxury most teams can’t afford, and DeVito’s skill set, while promising, isn’t irreplaceable.

Looking ahead, DeVito’s release opens up opportunities for him to explore new paths in the NFL. Whether as a backup or a practice squad player, his story is far from over.

What’s Next for Tommy DeVito? Potential Landing Spots

With his time in New York coming to an end, the question arises: where will Tommy DeVito land next? Several teams in need of quarterback depth could take a chance on him. His 2023 performance, where he threw 8 touchdowns and only 3 interceptions, combined with his marketing appeal, makes him an intriguing option for franchises looking for a low-risk, high-reward addition.

Teams like the Washington Commanders or the Chicago Bears, both of which have struggled with quarterback consistency, could benefit from DeVito’s presence. Additionally, his local roots in New Jersey make him a potential fit for teams in the Northeast looking to connect with their fanbase. While he may not be a long-term starter, his ability to step in during emergencies and his popularity among fans make him a viable candidate for a backup role.

DeVito’s best bet might be to join a team with a veteran starter. Teams like the Steelers or the Saints, where he can learn from experienced quarterbacks, would be ideal for his development.

Regardless of where he ends up, DeVito’s journey is a testament to the unpredictability of the NFL. His story serves as a reminder that talent alone isn’t always enough; timing and opportunity play significant roles in a player’s success.

The “Tommy Cutlets” Phenomenon: Why Giants Fans Loved Him

Tommy DeVito’s rise to cult-hero status among Giants fans can be attributed to several factors. First and foremost, his New Jersey roots resonated deeply with the local fanbase. Born and raised in the Garden State, DeVito’s underdog story of making it to the NFL as an undrafted free agent struck a chord with many.

Another key element was his agent, Sean Stellato, whose flamboyant sideline fashion became a viral sensation. Stellato’s larger-than-life personality added to the “Tommy Cutlets” lore, making DeVito’s journey feel even more relatable and entertaining. The nickname itself, inspired by DeVito’s love for pasta and his Italian heritage, became a symbol of blue-collar football fandom.

DeVito’s appeal goes beyond the field. His story is about perseverance, family, and the power of community. That’s why Giants fans will always remember him fondly.

Even after his release, fans flooded social media with memes of his signature touchdown celebration, where he mimicked eating pasta. The “Tommy Cutlets” phenomenon was more than just football; it was a celebration of culture, resilience, and the human spirit.

Tommy DeVito’s Contract Details and Net Worth Outlook

Tommy DeVito’s journey in the NFL has been financially modest compared to star quarterbacks. As an undrafted free agent, his initial 3-year contract with the Giants totaled $2.7 million, with minimal guarantees. His release in 2025 means he’ll carry a dead cap hit of $216,000, while his career NFL earnings stand at approximately $1.9 million.

Looking ahead, DeVito’s next deal is likely to be a veteran minimum contract, which would pay him around $1.1 million. While this may seem low, it’s a reflection of his position as a backup quarterback with limited starting experience. For DeVito, the focus now should be on securing a roster spot and continuing to develop his skills.

Money isn’t everything. For DeVito, the priority should be finding a team where he can continue to grow and prove himself. The financial rewards will come with sustained success.

While his net worth may not rival that of NFL superstars, DeVito’s story is a reminder that success isn’t always measured in dollars. His impact on the Giants and their fans is invaluable, and his journey is far from over.

Comparing DeVito to Other NFL Underdog Quarterbacks

History is filled with quarterbacks who, like Tommy DeVito, overcame the odds to make their mark in the NFL. Three paths stand out as potential comparisons for DeVito’s future:

1. The Kurt Warner Path

Kurt Warner, an undrafted quarterback, went from stocking shelves at a grocery store to leading the St. Louis Rams to a Super Bowl victory. While this path is rare, it serves as an inspiration for underdog quarterbacks everywhere.

2. The Case Keenum Path

Case Keenum, another undrafted quarterback, carved out a successful career as a journeyman. While he never became a long-term starter, his ability to step in during crucial moments earned him a place in the league for over a decade.

3. The Tim Tebow Path

Tim Tebow, a cult hero in Denver, led the Broncos to a playoff victory but struggled to find long-term success in the NFL. His story is a reminder that popularity and talent don’t always translate to sustained success.

DeVito’s future likely lies somewhere between Case Keenum and Tim Tebow. He may not become a superstar, but his resilience and charisma could keep him in the league for years to come.

Regardless of which path DeVito follows, his story is a testament to the unpredictability of the NFL. His journey serves as a reminder that with hard work and determination, anything is possible.