As Week 6 of the 2025 fantasy football season approaches, the Chase Brown vs. Javonte Williams debate reaches a critical juncture. Brown’s explosive potential in Cincinnati’s offense clashes with Williams’ role as Dallas’ workhorse back, leaving managers torn between upside and reliability.
Both RBs face favorable matchups, but their divergent 2025 trajectories complicate start/sit decisions. Williams’ 5.3 YPC and three touchdowns make him the safer play, while Brown’s dwindling carries (2.0 YPC) demand caution unless Zack Moss misses time. This showdown could define fantasy fortunes for playoff-bound teams.
- Chase Brown’s 2025 performance has declined (2.0 YPC), hampered by Cincinnati’s 28th-ranked O-line and Zack Moss’s increasing snap share (42% in Week 5).
- Javonte Williams emerges as the safer fantasy start, ranking as RB6 with 5.3 YPC and superior red-zone usage (6 inside-20 carries) in Dallas’s top-3 run-blocking offense.
- Week 6 matchup favors Williams against Detroit’s 23rd-ranked run defense, while Brown faces Seattle’s improving linebackers, limiting his receiving upside.
- Rest-of-season outlook strongly favors Williams (RB6 ECR, 14th-easiest schedule) over Brown (RB33 ECR, 9th-toughest schedule), barring a Zack Moss injury.
Chase Brown Week 6 Fantasy Analysis: Can He Outperform Javonte Williams?
The fantasy football community is split on whether Chase Brown justifies a Week 6 start over Javonte Williams. Brown’s 2024 late-season explosion (5.7 YPC Weeks 9-17) created sky-high expectations, but 2025 tells a different story. Through 5 games, he’s averaging just 2.3 yards per carry behind Cincinnati’s 28th-ranked offensive line. Meanwhile, Williams thrives in Dallas with 82.3 rushing yards per game and elite 5.3 YPC efficiency.
Three critical factors favor Williams:
- Usage: 67% snap share vs. Brown’s 40%
- TD equity: 6 red-zone carries to Brown’s 2
- O-line: Cowboys rank 3rd in run blocking vs. Bengals’ 28th
The Efficiency Metrics That Tell the True Story
| Stat | Chase Brown | Javonte Williams |
|---|---|---|
| Yards After Contact/Att | 1.3 (35th) | 2.8 (6th) |
| Breakaway Run % | 3.2% | 8.7% |
Javonte Williams: The Safer Fantasy Play With Hidden Upside
Williams isn’t just a volume play – his analytical profile reveals elite traits. Among RBs with 50+ carries, he ranks:
- 4th in Elusive Rating (112.3)
- 6th in Missed Tackles Forced (13)
- 2nd in % of Yards After Contact (67.3%)
The Cowboys’ scheme deserves credit. Their outside zone runs create 1.7 yards before contact (3rd-best), giving Williams runway to build momentum. His Week 6 opponent Detroit allows 4.9 YPC on zone concepts – expect 20+ touches against this vulnerable front.
Is Chase Brown Still Worth a Roster Spot?
Brown’s situation demands careful evaluation. While his usage is concerning, several factors suggest holding:
- Zack Moss’ contract expires after 2025
- Bengals have 5th-easiest RB schedule Weeks 14-17
- 13.7% target share in 3rd down situations
Stash Scenarios Where Brown Gains Value
- Joe Burrow returns to 2024 form (currently 22nd in QBR)
- O-line health improves (3 starters currently banged up)
- Zack Moss trade rumors materialize
Week 6 Start/Sit Verdict: Who Gets the Nod?
Our recommendation comes down to risk tolerance:
| RB | Ceiling | Floor |
|---|---|---|
| Javonte Williams | RB8 | RB18 |
| Chase Brown | RB12 | RB40 |
Long-Term Fantasy Outlook: 2025 Rest of Season Projections
Examining ROS schedules reveals stark contrasts:
- Williams: Faces only 2 top-10 run defenses
- Brown: 5 top-10 matchups including BAL x2
Advanced metrics suggest Williams maintains RB1 status while Brown needs multiple breaks to crack RB2 territory. In dynasty leagues, Williams’ youth (24 vs Brown’s 25) and situation cement him as the more valuable asset.
Comments