As the MLB trade deadline looms, Dustin May’s future with the Dodgers hangs in the balance. The 27-year-old right-hander’s inconsistent performances and injury history have made him a prime trade candidate, with the Yankees emerging as frontrunners for his services.
May’s recent struggles against the Red Sox – including a blown lead and key homer surrendered – may prove the final straw for Los Angeles. With Blake Snell’s impending return and May’s impending free agency, the Dodgers face a critical decision: capitalize on his remaining value now or risk losing him for nothing.
Could New York’s top prospects or an established star pitcher be heading to LA in exchange for May’s electric-but-unreliable arm? The clock is ticking as August 1st approaches.
- Dustin May’s inconsistent performance (4.73 ERA) and injury history make him a prime trade candidate as the Dodgers weigh offers before the deadline.
- The New York Yankees are frontrunners to acquire May, potentially offering top prospects like Spencer Jones or MLB-ready pitching in return.
- Possible three-team trade scenarios could see May dealt to NYY while the Dodgers land established starters like Pittsburgh’s Mitch Keller.
- Community reactions are split, with some fans calling May a “Ferrari with engine trouble” while others argue his high upside warrants patience.
Dodgers’ Dustin May Trade Rumors Swirl: Yankees’ Top Prospects or Star Pitcher Deal Before Deadline?
Why Dustin May Has Become the Hottest Name in Trade Talks
The MLB trade deadline pressure has crystallized around Dodgers’ right-hander Dustin May, whose unique combination of tantalizing potential and frustrating inconsistency makes him baseball’s most polarizing trade chip. The 27-year-old flamethrower owns a 4.73 ERA through 18 starts this season, yet his stuff remains among the most electric in the league when healthy. With Blake Snell’s impending return and May’s free agency clock ticking, Los Angeles faces increasing pressure to capitalize on his value.
May’s recent disastrous outing against Boston exemplified this dichotomy – blowing a 3-1 lead by surrendering a crushing two-run homer to Alex Bregman, yet still hitting 98 mph with movement late in the game. This duality explains why contenders like the Yankees see both risk and reward in acquiring May before the August 1 deadline.
The Yankees’ Desperate Pitching Search
New York’s interest stems from their dire rotation needs behind Gerrit Cole. The Yankees have:
- MLB’s 7th-worst rotation ERA (4.89) since June 1
- Just 12 quality starts from non-Cole pitchers
- Carlos Rodón’s continued health concerns
May represents a calculated gamble – trading future assets for controllable pitching with ace potential. However, his injury history (just 50 career starts since 2019 debut) makes the prospect cost particularly contentious.
Potential Trade Packages: What Could the Dodgers Realistically Get?
Industry sources suggest three possible frameworks for a May deal:
| Scenario | Yankees Receive | Dodgers Receive |
|---|---|---|
| Prospect-Heavy | Dustin May | OF Spencer Jones + RHP Clayton Beeter |
| Major League Swap | May + prospect | LHP Nestor Cortes |
| Three-Team Deal | May | PIT’s Mitch Keller + NYY’s prospect |
The Pirates emerge as potential facilitators given their veteran pitching surplus and need for young position players. A theoretical three-team framework could see Pittsburgh acquiring Yankees infield prospects while sending Keller to LA.
Why Spencer Jones Makes Sense for LA
The 6’6″ outfielder, ranked as New York’s No. 2 prospect, fits LA’s mold:
- .843 OPS at Double-A with 15 HR, 20 SB
- 80-grade raw power potential
- Could replace Jason Heyward long-term
Alternative Suitors if Yankees Talks Stall
While New York appears the frontrunner, several other contenders could enter the May sweepstakes:
Texas Rangers: The Sleeping Giant
Texas has:
- Depth of elite prospects (No. 3 ranked system)
- Urgent rotation needs (4.98 ERA since All-Star break)
- History of aggressive deadline moves
Package could center around OF Evan Carter or INF Justin Foscue – both MLB-ready talents who fit LA’s competitive window.
The Injury Factor: Calculating the Risk
May’s medical history presents the ultimate trade dilemma:
- 2021: Tommy John surgery (missed 14 months)
- 2023: Flexor strain (2 IL stints)
- 2024: Shoulder inflammation (missed April)
However, his underlying metrics suggest upside if healthy:
| Metric | May 2024 | MLB Avg |
|---|---|---|
| Fastball Velo | 97.2 mph | 93.9 mph |
| Whiff% | 29.1% | 23.4% |
| K/9 | 9.33 | 8.41 |
Medical Staff Evaluations Critical
Contenders will reportedly conduct extensive reviews of May’s medicals before finalizing any deal. The Dodgers’ legendary training staff has kept him relatively healthy since 2023 – can other teams replicate that success?
Final Prediction: Where May Lands Before Deadline
After analyzing all factors, the most likely outcome involves:
- Three-team trade between LAD, NYY, PIT
- Dodgers receive Mitch Keller + mid-level prospect
- Yankees get May for Spencer Jones + reliever
- Pirates land Yankees INF prospect + lottery ticket
This framework satisfies all parties’ needs while accounting for May’s risk/reward profile. The Dodgers secure a more reliable starter under team control, the Yankees bet on upside, and Pittsburgh continues rebuilding.
The Fallback Plan
Should talks collapse, the Dodgers could:
- Move May to bullpen for playoff push
- Keep him as depth for inevitable injuries
- Revisit trade discussions in offseason
One thing remains clear: with the deadline just hours away, Dustin May’s future will soon be decided – for better or worse.
Comments